Oddfellas Pub Auburn

59 reviews for “Oddfellas Pub Auburn”

1. Pulled pork mac & cheese was great

2. Didn’t have any food. Nothing personal swung by for drinks with friends. But service and atmosphere was awesome. Server did a hell of job. Would definitely reccomend

3. Been some years since I had ate here. Used to attend some free educational classes there concerning tractor trailers. The food was so dang good that when I happened to be staying locally at a hotel I saw Oddfellas on google maps and was pretty excited about ordering. Downloaded door dash, first time using any service like it, and ordered. Now I feel pretty embarrassed about spending 70 bucks on a meal for my daughter and myself. The Mac and cheese was literally elbows with two types of unmelted shredded cheese on top. After asking her if she liked it she told me, “ as much as you can like noodles with cheese on it.” They shorted me the gravy, dill cheesy bread and the fry’s came in a paper bag mixed with napkins and utensils. Mixed. Just solidifies the notion that one taking zero care in their work is society’s new norm . We all want everything for nothing and if anyone says anything to the contrary feelings get crushed. Well, I reckon this is the only way to hold folks accountable for sub standard service. Not much for complaining typically, here I am whining. However, it’s a very expensive bar/pub which in the past has delivered a delicious and hearty meal. Maybe an off night.

4. Gravy (sausage) had some pepper, wasn’t my thing but could be your thing.

5. Can’t wait to go back!

6. Something different between Seattle and Tacoma. Great staff and good food. Portions are huge, so order accordingly. Open later than other spots.

7. Great happy hour choices. Decent taps.

8. I really liked the tickle pickle tacos. Good service too. But ya cant find them on the menu anymore? Stay away from the Irish nachos. Yuck.

9. Gone a few times.. always a disappointment. Food wise. And expensive.

10. I have been dropping by here on occasion for the last couple of years. Have also ordered take-out a number of times. This is personally one of my favorite bar/restaurants in this area.

    Wait staff is ALWAYS super friendly. Have never had a bad experience. I like the atmosphere. Its like a dive bar vibe, but without being a dive. Very comfortable to me.

    Multiple beers on tap for those that like variety. Even my Dad who is a self-proclaimed “beer snob” likes to go here.

    The food is very good. Much better than your typical bar food. I have tried multiple menu items including their pizza, reuben, cottage pie, various appetizers – all of which was very good (which is why I have gotten take out here on occasion). The prices of the appetizers are near what the meals are, but thats pretty typical and the portion sizes are absolutely sharable. Pretty much the size of a meal.

    Seems like it would be a great place to watch the football game. They have a projector and multiple TVs around the place. However, times that I have gone here during a Seahawks/UW game, there hasn’t been that many people. So if you prefer a quieter spot for that, this is the place. But to be fair, when I have gone, interest in the Seahawks were kind of dwindling, so maybe people just decided to stay home.

    Overall I really like this place and would recommend it to anyone looking for a calmer atmosphere.

11. Here they sell lunch and dinner. Also go for drinks. It is a quiet place next to the bus station. Here in Auburn. The place is old. If you want to watch an American football game, this is the perfect place. It is better to go as a couple or friends..

12. Excellent atmosphere, excellent food, excellent service, a great place to hang out with your friends.

13. Great place for a pint and food. Centre of Auburn Downtown.

14. 🙂 Yummy spinach dip and drinks. Bartenders here are great too.

15. Good was great this time around the service was quick and didn’t have to wait for drinks spot on there great job guys.

16. It’s the second time I’ve been here. The first time I came was delicious wilcooked and the service was great. This time when I came I ordered fish-and-chips they were overcooked and the French fries were overcooked. The fish I had was almost black and the French fries were so overcooked. It was like eaten Styrofoam. Very dissatisfied with my food. But the service and the atmosphere was excellent.

17. Great little European style brew pub. It’s definitely not for everyone. You wouldn’t consider this place. Fine dining, but it is reminiscent of a lot of places I’ve been to in Europe.

18. More than you expect.
    This was my first time going into Oddfellas. I drive by several times a week but have never had the occasion to stop in.
    The food was great. I had the schnitzel and needed a nap afterwards.
    The staff was very friendly and helpful
    And the atmosphere was exactly what you’d want for a corner pub.
    I highly recommend stopping in but make sure to bring an appetite because the portions are huge!

19. Foods good and decently priced. Parking can be a pain sometimes. Nice place overall.

20. Wouldn’t serve drinks after 920. Closed at 10pm. Didn’t make sense

21. We’ve been here a couple times in the past and food and service was always good. This time, service was still good but the food wasn’t. My ribs we warm and not fall-off-the-bone tender like in the past. The flavor was also not great. They did throw it back on the grill for me but it didn’t change the taste much. Another person in the party ordered a steak which was very fatty, although was cooked to order.
    I will definitely give this place another chance since it could have just been an off night. If that next experience chances these results I’ll make sure to update this review.

22. Everything was delicious and reasonably priced. Great options with good variety. The Mac & cheese with sausage for my daughter was good and not boxed. I had Carlo’s Cuban and my other daughter had the pork candy. The Salads are a great option as well. Only negative thing is the upkeep of the bathrooms and the table tops could use some attention, sticky from wiping down the varnish over the years.

23. Everything I’ve had here was pretty good. Service has always been a little awkward. Vibes are good though. I really like the Chili. The white wine clams were good as well. Bit overpriced.

24. The menu names are hilarious, the food was mediocre. The service was fine. We didn’t wait forever like we did last time, and our order was right this time. It’s kinda noisy in there. I tried something different today than my usual go-tos. I was looking forward to the crispy tortilla like it said in the menu. It was completely soggy. Plus my kid’s fish was cold on the outer sides – prob waiting too long to get to our table, or just outside of frozen. We went on a Friday night. The place should have been humming. Also, it irritates me I have to pay a surcharge on card transactions.

25. My bill had a “surcharge fee”. I asked and was directed to “Diamond” the manager. Diamond attempted to tell me that they had done their “market research” and determined that they needed to surcharge anyone using a credit card. I attempted to get clarity as to the naming on the bill and was shown a VERY small sign at the door declaring that anyone using a credit card would have to pay a 3% surcharge. Considering the large chalk board said “seat yourself”, I didn’t chose to look at any other signage. I would only return if I chose to go to an ATM and withdrew cash, but this is unlikely to happen.

26. For context, I am a professional cook in upscale dining. I ordered the mac. Without a shadow of a doubt I got Stouffer’s mac and cheese. Overdone noodles with that signature bright color and lack of flavor. No salt or pepper was added either. The website describes this dish as “We hand craft this dish with a secret cheese recipe, custom elbow macaroni.” Are you kidding me for 15.99 I am getting that when I expect to get something from scratch. If there is no demand take it off the menu. Pasta and cheese is already such a crazy profit margin for 15.99. Do better take it off the menu. This is either greed or laziness.

27. Wow
    What can I say. The food was amazing and our waitress was a beautiful young lady and the menu will have you laughing but the drinks are off the hook
    Thank you
    Kevin

28. Michelle was our waitress and she was attentive without being intrusive. Was helpful with information about the food, the bar history, things to do in Auburn.
    We enjoyed our meal and the atmosphere. Looking forward to going there in the evening sometime.

29. Good food great Irish Pub!

30. Our chicken was completely raw. It didn’t even look like there was an attempt to cook it. I took a bite and it was so hard that I had to spit it out. And it was completely uncooked chicken, bright pink. It’s not letting me upload a photo at this time but if it does, I will attach it. We ordered too much food so didn’t notice until we got home.

31. Corned beef meal tasted so good. Just wish the portions were bigger for twenty dollars

32. the food was pretty mid here. one of the chicken wings came with a feather fried on it. the server said it happens all the time??

33. My girlfriend and I decided to try this place out after she passed it a few times going to work. So, we went for an early dinner. It wasn’t too busy and we got seated right away. The atmosphere was nice. You had your bar area with the high top tables and then booths and tables in the restaurant area with a high top large group table in the middle.

    The waitress was very friendly and gave us suggestions based on the things she likes there.
    Once we decided, it came fairly quickly.

    I lived in Germany for many years and so I decided to try the schnitzel, it didn’t disappoint.

    The only disappointment was at the end of the meal. When I saw there was a 3% fee for paying with a credit card. I don’t like hidden costs and I would never expect to pay a business expense to pay them for my meal. In my opinion, it’s a terrible business practice to pass along your business costs to your customers.
    Had I known before my meal I could’ve made a decision to stay or come back another time with cash. I think that we pay too many fees on top of fees these days.
    So, if you decide to try this place out, unless you don’t mind paying 3% more to pay for your meal, bring cash.
    Otherwise it was a pleasant visit. So, I’m sure I would go again, I just have to remember to bring cash.

    Parking: Parking is limited. There is a small lot next to the restaurant and then street parking. It wasn’t too busy when I was there but it might be hard to find parking on busier nights.

34. The food was amazing and the service was excellent!

35. Very cool place for lunch, personally recommend to have the steak.

36. The atmosphere of this place nails the cozy, exciting, pub energy. The service is fast, the staff is friendly and welcoming. My partner and I ordered the big a** pretzel and the bangers and mash. They don’t lie when they say that pretzel is huge and the cheese options are delicious. But, hands down, the best bangers and mash I have had. Right next to my mom’s, of course

37. Had a good time here. It’s very much ur typical pub atmosphere with great snacks for drinking and hanging out. I would have loved more sauce on the grinder, but it was decent. The poutine was good, but the gravy could have been better. Overall, pretty good.

38. Typical pub style food, really great service, decent tap list and beer specials 👍. Would recommend the pulled pork quesadilla and chicken wings. The mac n cheese looked a little runny and not too cheesy…not sure how it tasted 🤷.

39. Had the pork schnitzel with mashed potatoes. The biscuit muffin was so good fluffy and perfect.

40. The steak was great, but it’s their Big A** Brownie that really hit the spot. Try their lemonade blend too!! (I was with a group and the DD so I couldn’t comment on their alcohol selection)

41. Great pub great food

42. Sarah, our server was great. She was attentive and funny. The food was sub standard. The burgers were dry. The French frys were limp. The coleslaw was flavorless. What caused us to never come again was the surcharge. You realize that will be taken out of the servers tip. Fix your finances without charging the customer more.

43. Food was awful. Steak was completely raw in the middle and portions were very small for the price. Service was mediocre at best. Definitely would not return.

44. Always a favorite when I go get my hair cut at Third Dimension Salon. The food, drinks and service are excellent but my favorite is the candied pork bites!

45. If I could rate this place any higher I would. The other day I was struck down by the worst upper respiratory infection of my life. I couldn’t care for myself. I ordered their cottage pie, as hot, soft food was all that I could handle and it was amazing. It even came piping hot. They are amazing for making this available for delivery. I have so, so, so much gratitude for this establishment.

46. I give this place 5 stars overall because of the staff. A man came into the bar and did not have enough money to pay for his beer. As I reached into my pocket to buy the man a beer, the bartender beat me to the punch and gave him a free beer. The bartender then welcomed the man with open arms to sit down and enjoy the AC while he drank his beer. This type of hospitality is not common in Auburn and I was extremely proud to see a business take care of the community. I’m not advising to go try to get free drinks but it’s nice to know these people run their business with their hearts and not their wallets or preconceived notions. Well done!

47. Sandwich was a bit dry. Had to ask for more mayo. Tater Tots were great.

48. I had the Irish nachos and Cottage Pie. Yes, that’s a lot of potatoes! The Irish nachos were very good. They’re essential topped tots and it’s nice to share them. I enjoyed the Cottage Pie at it’s very similar to a Shepard’s Pie. The gravy served on the side is a nice addition too.

    I stopped in today and tried a pepperoni flatbread and banger & mash. They were tasty.

    The atmosphere was pleasant. It’s a bar/pub vibe with 80’s hits playing over the sound system. Both my wife and I were very pleased.

    Lastly, service was top notch. Our waitress was very affable and accommodating.

49. This is great place for Happy Hour. Great food, great service, fun atmosphere. We shared the Irish Nachos, huge portion for $7. I got the schnitzel sandwich and fries with a side of gravy. My husband got the cottage pie. We shared an order of dill dough. Every twas very flavorful. Very good.

50. The Shepherd’s pie is excellent. Great selection of beers. Watch out for the hidden service charge. Burgers were over cooked and the fries were limp.

51. Visited for dinner Saturday night – Sarah was our server and she was great! Shared a couple of appetizers – varied food and beer menu

52. Great food, cool place. Parking kinda sucks.

53. Oddfellas is a restaurant in Auburn that’s close to the train tracks right off the highway. Parking around here can very a pain sometimes so you might have to walk a bit to get here. Inside they have dozens of tables and a bar area, alongside plenty of TVs everywhere playing mostly sports. Their menu is quite large so they have a lot of options. Portion sizes are generous but prices are very high for what you get. Flavors are alright, nothing too crazy – the Cuban sandwich was ok and the cottage pie was pretty good. The staff are friendly but very slow, we saw are server only once after our food came and it was just for the check (which was about 30 minutes post food delivered to the table). Overall this place is fine, it’s got its ups and downs but I can see it being a great place to watch sports with friends for drinks.

54. Not that great. Food is mediocre and there’s plenty of other places around for beer. The sandwiches and burgers are okayish but the cottage pie, bangers and mash, etc are all pretty bland.

55. Great breakfast, great service and quick food delivery to our table.

56. The food is great! Nearly everything we’ve tried has been a hit, especially the mashed potatoes. But this place could use a good cleaning and dusting. If you go here, don’t look up or you won’t be able to eat. The hanging lights right above the tables and the vents are coated with old dirt. I wish they could clean and dust. These are common areas visible to the public and right where food is served! Management, think about food safety and hygiene and do the right thing.

57. Sausage and mash was excellent

58. Service was fantastic. Food was very good. Very very cool ambience

59. Good food, friendly server